In one corner, the old school pro, whose reputation precedes them and who can do no more than repeat their long-established, hammy, act. In the other, a plucky outsider many ridicule for being amateurish and simply not up to the job.
But enough of Jeremy Paxman and Kay Burley, who hosted The Battle for Number 10 last night.
The first television encounter of this election was defined by what it was not. It was not a debate – David Cameron and Ed Miliband instead traded questions with Paxman and a docile studio audience. It was not a game-changer - too few will have watched it for that. And it did not, much, apparently, alter the perceptions of those viewers who did tune inRead More
When I wrote A State of Play. British Politics on the Screen, Stage and Page, From Anthony Trollope to The Thick of It I didn’t deliberately seek out fictions with a Manchester or Salford connection.
But when I started to see if I could construct a talk for the Post Box in what even the Guardian refers to as the 'Guardian-reading heaven' that is Chorlton on April 24th (the details of which are here) I found that a large number of fictions I talk about were set in the cities or written by or starred those who had lived in them.
This is a reflection of the importance of Manchester and Salford to Britain’s political culture, for asRead More
Last week I gave a lecture as part of my final year undergraduate Fictionalised Politics course, which looks at how representative politics - let's just call it 'democracy' - is depicted in Britain and the United States.
The basic proposition is that fictional representations matter because they do more than (imperfectly) reflect how we imagine our our real democracy: they can also shape how we come to think about it. I develop some of the themes in the course in my book A State of Play, which focuses just on British political fiction.
In the lecture I talked about gender as the ‘social organization of sexual difference’, the meanings ofRead More
Most of the reactions to the death of Tony Benn have focused on the man who turned left in the 1970s, embraced union militancy and became ‘the most dangerous man in Britain’. That was, however, Benn Mark II, arguably the less interesting version, and certainly the one less relevant to our own times, when the parties are desperately seeking to regain a connection with the people.
A while back I wrote a book about how Labour responded to the many cultural changes generated in the 1960s. In that decade Benn emerged as one of the party’s few leading figures who tried to seriously think though how the party might engage with at least some of them.
Benn Mark I was a fairly conventional politician. In the 1950s he was something of a revisionist and in the 1960s an enthusiastic if idiosyncratic member of Harold Wilson’s inner circle.Read More
Already hailed for its 'brilliant analysis' by John Rentoul my new book A State of Play was published on April 24th, and should be available in the book shops now, but of not, you can order it direct from from Bloomsbury.
The book speaks for itself, of course. And here's a limited preview of its contents. But just in case it doesn't, I'll be doing a few talks about the relationship between politics and political fiction over the next few months.
Further details and more dates will be added when things become clearer.
Tuesday April 8th: at the Social History History annual conference, I talked about 'Fiction and politics in 1970s television dramas'.
Thursday April 24th: at the Post Box in Chorlton, I talked about 'Manchester and Salford in PoliticalRead More
Conservative Education Secretary Michael Gove recently grabbed the headlines by claiming Britons mistakenly think the 1914-18 conflict a ‘misbegotten shambles’ partly because that’s what Blackadder told them it was. To rather less fanfare, last autumn Defence minister Andrew Murrison and Jeremy Paxman said very much the same thing. And before Gove turned the issue into a party spat, Dan Jarvis, Labour’s shadow Justice minister, argued Blackadder promoted an erroneous ‘pointless futility’ narrative about the war.
Blackadder is not alone in constituting that which Gove described as the ‘fictional prism’ throughRead More
I’ve spent the last few years of my life immersed in stories of various kinds, stories about British democracy. So metaphor and simile have been my meat and drink, as it were.
Perhaps I’ve done a bit too much of all that, as I was watching Deal or No Deal recently and had something close to an epiphany. As I was in the gym when it happened, doing my nut on a cross-trainer while watching the show thanks to subtitles, perhaps too much oxygen had also got into my brain.
Because, to my addled mind, it struck me that the Channel 4 quiz show Deal or No Deal is a metaphor for Britain.Read More
On Twitter recently, Ben Page of Ipsos MORI compared levels of public trust in judges, civil servants and politicians in 1983 and 2013, findings that form part of his organisation's ongoing survey of popular trust in various professions' ability to tell the truth.
As you can see below, he points out that judges are slightly more trusted today while politicians still lurk at a very low level indeed.
But something remarkable has happened to trust in civil servants: it has more than doubled.Read More